Frankie and the Nervous Save

| | Comments (0)

Recently, during one of the game threads on Halos Heaven, someone made a comment about Francisco Rodriguez getting a "nervous" save.  What was meant by a "nervous" save (NS) was that K-Rod always seemed to get the save, but he allowed base runners causing the save to be risky.  The comment got me to thinking about how often Rodriguez allowed base runners during his save opportunities compared to other closers.  I went through the top 20 closers (based on Saves) and counted the number of times during a save opportunity that the pitcher allowed more than one hitter to get on base, either by a combination of hits and/or walks.  Here's what I found:

Closer Saves NS NS%
Mariano Rivera - NYY 32 2 6%
Kerry Wood - CHC 28 2 7%
Trevor Hoffman - SD 27 3 11%
Billy Wagner - NYM 27 3 11%
Jose Valverde - Hou 39 5 13%
Jonathan Papelbon - Bos 35 6 17%
Joakim Soria - KC 34 6 18%
Bobby Jenks - CWS 27 5 19%
Brian Fuentes - Col 26 5 19%
Salomon Torres - Mil 26 5 19%
Francisco Cordero - Cin 26 5 19%
Joe Nathan - Min 36 7 19%
Kevin Gregg - Fla 29 6 21%
Brian Wilson - SF 36 8 22%
Francisco Rodriguez - LAA 54 12 22%
Brandon Lyon - Ari 26 6 23%
George Sherrill - Bal 31 9 29%
Troy Percival - TB 27 8 30%
Brad Lidge - Phi 33 10 30%
B.J. Ryan - Tor 26 8 31%
625 121 19%

K-Rod was a bit worse than the average top 10 closer percentage-wise, but ranked 15th out of 20 (ranking lower than former Angels Kevin Gregg and Bobby Jenks).  Apparently K-Rod was making Angels' fans more nervous than the average closer.  One of the interesting results was Philadelphia's Brad Lidge's numbers.  He has the second highest NS percentage, but has yet to blow a save.  I guess he likes pitching in high pressure situations - if he doesn't inherit one, he makes his own.  Anyway, these numbers got me thinking about Frankie's quest for the single season saves record (57) and what other closers would project to do if they were in Rodriguez's place.  This is a pretty big assumption, but I thought it'd be interesting to see how other pitchers would do if their save conversion rate was used in the same number of save situations K-Rod had been in.  Frankie has converted 54 saves out of 59 opportunities (92%).  Below are the projected save totals for the same top 20 closers as above:

Closer Saves Save Opp Projected
Brad Lidge - Phi 33 33 59
Mariano Rivera - NYY 32 33 57
Brian Wilson - SF 36 39 54
Joakim Soria - KC 34 37 54
Francisco Rodriguez - LAA 54 59 54
Troy Percival - TB 27 30 53
Bobby Jenks - CWS 27 30 53
Jonathan Papelbon - Bos 35 39 53
B.J. Ryan - Tor 26 29 53
Joe Nathan - Min 36 41 52
Trevor Hoffman - SD 27 31 51
Jose Valverde - Hou 39 45 51
Brian Fuentes - Col 26 30 51
Kerry Wood - CHC 28 33 50
Brandon Lyon - Ari 26 31 49
George Sherrill - Bal 31 37 49
Salomon Torres - Mil 26 32 48
Francisco Cordero - Cin 26 32 48
Billy Wagner - NYM 27 34 47
Kevin Gregg - Fla 29 38 45


Brad Lidge would project out to have already broken the record, that is if he hadn't given everyone a heart attack from allowing so many base runners.  Also notice Mariano Rivera would have tied the record at this point in the season, as would Soria and Wilson.  Rivera is one of the all-time greatest closers, and this year his conversion rate is outstanding (one blown save).  If the Yankees had provided Rivera with as many opportunities K-Rod has had, he would probably have a greater chance of getting the saves record.

I'm not trying to rip on K-Rod, he's an outstanding closer, but he's been afforded more save opportunities than any other closer.  If one of the other top closers were in the same situation, the results would probably be the same...if not better.

Daily Notes:

  • Joe Saunders didn't pitch great last night, but he did pitch well enough to get the win had Scot Shields been able to hold the lead in the 8th inning.  I have a hard time understanding the need for managers to use their pitchers only in their designated roles.  Shields has been the primary set-up guy for K-Rod, usually pitching just the 8th inning.  Last night, Jose Arredondo entered the game with one out in the 7th and needed just 9 pitches to get the two batters he faced.  Why didn't Arredondo come back out and pitch the 8th?  I suppose if Shields had gotten out of the 8th without giving up any runs I wouldn't be asking this question, but he gave up a home run to Miguel Cabrera to tie the game.  This also applies to K-Rod and only pitching the 9th inning.  If he's the best pitcher in the pen, why not use him when the game is really on the line, like say, the 8th inning and 2 runners on with less than 1 out?  Now that would be a save, not entering the game with no one on.  Anyway, maybe this subject is a post for another day.
  • Angels' rookies Brandon Wood and Sean Rodriguez are still struggling at the plate, but are providing good defense.  Last night Wood made a spectacular play on a ground ball to his right.  Wood made a diving, backhanded stop, got to one knee and started a 6-4-3 double play.  Later in the same inning, Rodriguez made a great sliding catch in foul territory.
  • Magic number:  7 (with 25 games remaining).  The Angels are .5 game behind Tampa for home field advantage.

Leave a comment



About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Jim published on September 3, 2008 11:58 AM.

Halo Heaven's Mat Gleason, a.k.a. Rev Halofan - Part 1 was the previous entry in this blog.

Angels Video is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Powered by Movable Type 4.01